Is Dominance Training An Unnecessary Dog Training Technique Today?

There is a lot of disagreement on whether dominance dog training is ethical. Mainly you must show your dog that you are the alpha and the dog must essentially be subservient to you in every way. It is believed by some experts that all dogs want to be the alpha in any relationship whether it is with other dogs or dog and pet owner. They believe you may need to use punishment on the dog if you want to succeed in being the alpha over the dog. Many also believe this dominant trait in dogs has evolved out of their evolution and it is not necessary to punish the dog or engage in dominant dog training.

Dog training has evolved over the years, and as more research is conducted on canine behavior and psychology, there is a growing consensus that dominance training is an unnecessary and potentially harmful technique. Dominance training involves the use of physical force, intimidation, and punishment to establish a dominant relationship between the dog and the owner. However, this approach to training has been criticized for its negative effects on dogs and its lack of effectiveness in promoting good behavior. In this article, we will explore why dominance training is an unnecessary dog training technique today.

Firstly, the idea of dominance theory has been debunked by numerous studies. The idea that dogs are inherently trying to dominate their owners is based on an outdated theory that was popularized by animal behaviorist Dr. Rudolph Schenkel in the 1940s. However, more recent research has shown that dogs are not trying to dominate their owners but are simply trying to communicate their needs and desires. In fact, dogs are highly social animals and thrive on positive relationships with their owners. Dominance training can damage this relationship by creating fear and mistrust in the dog, leading to a range of behavioral problems.

Secondly, dominance training can cause physical and emotional harm to dogs. Physical punishment, such as hitting or alpha rolling, can cause physical harm to the dog, including broken bones, bruises, and internal injuries. Emotional harm can also result from this type of training, leading to fear, anxiety, and even aggression in the dog. These negative effects can be long-lasting and can lead to a breakdown in the relationship between the owner and the dog.

Thirdly, there are more effective and humane methods of training that do not involve dominance theory. Positive reinforcement training is a technique that rewards good behavior with treats, praise, and other rewards. This technique has been shown to be highly effective in promoting good behavior and building a strong bond between the dog and the owner. In fact, positive reinforcement training has been endorsed by the American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior as the preferred method of training for dogs.

Fourthly, dominance training can be counterproductive and can actually exacerbate behavioral problems. Dogs that are trained using dominance techniques may become more aggressive, fearful, or anxious, as they associate their owner with punishment and negative experiences. This can lead to a range of behavioral problems, including aggression towards humans and other dogs, separation anxiety, and destructive behavior.

Lastly, dominance training is not necessary to establish leadership with a dog. Dogs are pack animals and are naturally inclined to follow a strong and confident leader. Establishing leadership can be achieved through positive reinforcement training, which focuses on building a strong bond between the dog and the owner. This bond is built on mutual trust, respect, and understanding, and can lead to a happy and well-behaved dog.

In conclusion, dominance training is an unnecessary and potentially harmful dog training technique that has been debunked by numerous studies. Positive reinforcement training is a more effective and humane method of training that promotes good behavior and builds a strong bond between the dog and the owner. Dominance training can cause physical and emotional harm to dogs and can lead to a range of behavioral problems. By focusing on positive reinforcement training, owners can establish a strong bond with their dog, promote good behavior, and build a happy and healthy relationship.